The journey of analyzing torture genre movies comes to an end with this post, at least for the time being. There is one thing I have missed in this string of posts and that is to look at the profitability of the movies in depth. Hope I will write one for that later on sometime. But, that one will be more mathematical oriented analysis rather than a cerebral string of reasoning.
Now, before coming to the actual point of this post, I want to narrate a story. This is a story of an episode from my current favorite series “Boston Legal”. So, as it happens, there is this divorced guy who has issues with his ex and who has fantasies of killing her. As a person, he is a very docile guy and people don’t expect any such fantasies from him. Now, as is the fashion (or perhaps a necessity) in US, he has his psychologist who gets paid for hearing to this guy’s traumas and gives consultation. And this doctor gets into dilemma after hearing to the guy’s very violent fantasy and decides to tell the ex-wife. The lady obviously gets scared and wants to call the police but the doctor asks her to wait and just be alert. The guy comes to know of this and wants to sort the things and make it clear to his ex that he won’t ever do anything like that. He goes to the lady’s place who gets frightened on seeking him. And in the next scene, we see the police arriving at the place and the guy dead.
The above incident, though it’s a story from a teleseries, can very well be a real incident. Human brain is a very convoluted and dark place. There are lots of things which are social taboo and still a regular phenomenon in brains of people. And there’s a necessity for an outlet for these thoughts. Leave alone taboo (let me clarify that the taboo need not be sexual) thoughts, even the usual feeling of being left alone or being disparaged or laughed at, if not vented through some mechanism, may lead to very disastrous results. So, how bad is it if people who get violent dreams or who may have such feelings occasionally mustering in them get an outlet in form of the torture genre cinema? Isn’t it good if such feelings can get calmed down or satisfied watching a false torture scene than to actually performing such heinous act after getting frustrated?
I guess it’s not an easy question to answer. It’s very subjective and then, there is a total diagonal viewpoint to it too. I will touch upon it, but just a tad bit later. For now, let me relate the usability of such a torture genre movie to another profession – prostitution. I don’t carry a very strong view about the acceptability of the profession but from whatever little I understand I think that if somehow the atrocities and bad conditions can be removed from the profession, then, perhaps legitimizing the profession isn’t that bad. Sure, the class of prostitutes might be looked upon with but then how many of us are actually there who don’t look down a person we think aren’t as capable as we are? Anyways, apart from the social cause of legitimizing the profession and giving a chance to those women to not get subjected to horrifying life, I have a certain other rationale for legitimizing the profession. Once not long back, I read the news that two guys raped a fourth standard girl who would be barely nine years old. Nine year old girl getting raped? What the hell? Are these guys even worth being called men? Not that I support the rape of girl of any age, but how can one get stimulated by raping a nine year old? Well, perhaps that’s the problem. That the human brain just works in mysterious way. The frustration that builds up gets an outlet in very ugly ways sometimes. And somehow I am pretty sure that it’s not the age of the girl that played a part, but the opportunity of going after a meek organism. Not that I am unaware that there are pedophiles also walking the surface of this earth but it’s just my feeling that the rogue was sexually frustrated and he saw the outlet in a female who could not do much about his heinous act. Now, if that’s the case and had prostitution been an easily accessible and not so costly affair, perhaps, such an incident might not have happened.
I guess it’s perhaps pretty clear what I intend to say from the above – the same thing about providing people with an outlet for their emotions; the emotions which are hard to accept, not very common and which when realized lead to disaster. Now, going back to my story of the guy fantasizing of violently killing his ex, there’s another small thing to ponder over there. The guy gets killed because the wife gets afraid knowing about his fantasy even though in reality the guy is pretty non-violent which even the wife knows. But then, that is how we operate, isn’t it? If we get a dream, we link it to some sub-conscious feeling we may have and extrapolate it to predict our behavior. In a very similar way, if we get to know that a person enjoys sadistic behavior and enjoys watching a cinema of torture genre, we tend to have a very negative view about him or her. I have experienced this with myself too when I got disgusted that how can one enjoy such gruesome killing scenes and such plots where torturing people and killing them is seen as something enjoyable. In a similar vein, suppose you get to know that one of your same sex friend is gay, won’t you get wary of him or her? But is it that since you are a hetro, you are interested in each and every person of opposite sex? So, why this extrapolation? Well, I guess it is so because a person simply isn’t defined by what he himself is, but also by the mirror of society in which his image develops. And well, then, there is another concept of risk and return playing here too. How risky is it to maintain a relationship with a gay friend in lieu of the returns (emotional or otherwise) you will get? Well, I guess if it’s a close friend the risk of you being subjected to some gay love is pretty underplayed but if it’s the risk of losing your life and that too after being subjected to a sadistic unearthly torture, then, the risks just multiply manifolds. And perhaps that’s one of the reasons why we (people who keep away from torture movies) form opinion about people who love torture cinema. And though, we can’t 100% say that the person is sadistic and will kill someone but the probability certainly is higher than a person who doesn’t like it.
Now, the diagonal viewpoint about what’s bad in these kind of movies. Well, I guess they are more than obvious and need no explanation. With the violent video games taking over the world and killings reported by children, it’s no news how these kind of movies can very well effect the people enjoying it. So, I will refrain myself from delving into it. As it is, the entry has already gone pretty long :) . And with this, I will conclude my string of write-ups about the torture genre movies with a hope that these sort of movies actually do some good which goes on unreported in media but helps the society to exist in peace.









